The choice between building a new home and buying an existing property represents one of the most significant decisions in your home buying journey. Both options have genuine advantages, and the right choice depends on your priorities, timeline, and financial situation.
This is not a decision to make lightly. Each path involves different costs, timeframes, risks, and rewards. Understanding these differences helps you choose the option that genuinely suits your needs rather than following assumptions about which is better.
The Case for Building New
New homes offer certainty about what you are getting. Modern building standards mean better insulation, double glazing throughout, efficient heating, and materials that meet current earthquake requirements. The Healthy Homes standards that landlords must meet are already exceeded by new construction.
Everything is new and under warranty. Master Build Guarantee or similar schemes provide protection against defects for up to 10 years. Maintenance requirements are minimal initially, and you avoid inheriting problems like leaky building syndrome, asbestos, or old wiring.
You get exactly what you want. Room layouts, kitchen design, bathroom specifications, and storage solutions all match your preferences rather than compromising on someone else's choices. For many buyers, this customisation represents the primary appeal of building.
New builds also offer favourable deposit requirements. Banks typically accept a 10 percent deposit for new construction compared to 20 percent for existing homes. This makes building accessible to buyers who might struggle to reach the standard deposit threshold.
The Case for Buying Existing
Existing homes offer something new builds cannot: immediate certainty. You know exactly what you are buying because it already exists. There are no surprises about how the finished home will look or function. What you see at the open home is what you get at settlement.
The process is faster and simpler. From making an offer to moving in typically takes six to twelve weeks. Building takes twelve to eighteen months or longer. For buyers who need to move quickly, existing homes provide the only viable option.
Established neighbourhoods come with existing infrastructure. Schools have track records you can research. Neighbours are already in place. Trees have grown, gardens have matured, and the street has a character you can assess before committing.
Price transparency also favours existing homes. Recent sales of comparable properties provide clear market evidence of value. With new builds, comparing costs across builders and specifications is considerably more difficult.
Financial Comparison
The financial equation is not straightforward. New builds often appear more expensive on paper, but the comparison requires careful analysis.
Building costs per square metre typically exceed the per-square-metre cost of buying existing. However, new builds come with lower maintenance requirements, better energy efficiency, and modern fixtures that would cost extra to add to an older home. Over 10 or 20 years, these factors can offset the initial premium.
Land costs distort the comparison significantly. In areas where sections are scarce and expensive, the combined land and build cost may exceed what an equivalent existing home would cost. In areas with available sections at reasonable prices, building becomes more competitive.
Running costs favour new builds. Better insulation means lower heating bills. Modern efficient appliances use less power and water. These savings compound over time, though they rarely offset a substantial price difference in the short term.
Risk Considerations
Building carries risks that buying existing does not. Construction delays happen regularly, and weather, material shortages, or builder capacity can push completion dates back by months. Your timeline needs flexibility.
Cost overruns remain a genuine concern despite fixed-price contracts. Allowances for kitchens, bathrooms, and finishes may not cover what you actually want. Site conditions can reveal unexpected expenses. Changes during construction cost more than changes at planning stage.
Builder failure, while uncommon, does occur. Guarantees provide some protection, but the disruption of your builder going into liquidation mid-project creates stress and delay that no warranty fully compensates.
Existing homes carry different risks. Building reports should reveal major issues, but they cannot see inside walls or predict future problems. Older homes may require significant maintenance spending that is difficult to anticipate. However, these risks are generally more predictable than construction risks.
Timeline and Lifestyle Factors
Your current living situation significantly influences the decision. Renters face continued rent payments throughout the building process. Those selling an existing home need bridging finance or temporary accommodation.
Building requires ongoing involvement. Decisions about selections, site visits, and communication with your builder consume time and mental energy. Some people enjoy this involvement while others find it stressful.
For growing families, timing matters. A new baby arriving mid-construction creates additional pressure. School zones may be relevant if your new build sits in a different catchment from your current location.
Location Considerations
Some locations offer only one realistic option. Established suburbs with few vacant sections effectively limit you to existing homes. New subdivisions in growth areas may offer only new builds with no existing stock available.
Infrastructure varies between established and developing areas. New subdivisions may lack public transport, nearby shops, and community facilities that established suburbs provide. These factors affect daily life and long-term property values.
Making Your Decision
The right choice depends on weighing your specific priorities. Consider how much customisation matters to you, whether you can accommodate construction delays, your tolerance for project management responsibilities, and your financial flexibility.
Neither option is objectively better. Building suits buyers who prioritise specifications, energy efficiency, and modern design, and who can accommodate extended timelines. Existing homes suit buyers who prioritise speed, location in established suburbs, and certainty about what they are buying.
Talk to a mortgage adviser about how each option affects your borrowing capacity and deposit requirements. The financial structures differ significantly, and understanding these differences helps inform your decision.
Need Help With Your Mortgage?
Our expert advisers are here to guide you through every step of your mortgage journey. Get in touch for a free, no-obligation consultation.
Talk to an Adviser
